In the US Market, iPhone Outperforms Other Mobile Platforms in User Loyalty by a Wide Margin, Android is Second, Blackberry Fourth
Zokem’s industry leading Mobile Life panel in the US from the year 2010 reveals that iPhone scores 84% higher in loyalty ratings than the nearest competitor, Google Android. Among non-iPhone users, the number one preference for the next smartphone is iPhone. The benchmark results by Zokem also show that older Windows Mobile devices and Nokia’s Symbian devices have already lost the game in the US. Both Microsoft and Nokia are, however, coming back with new offerings and trying to challenge the top three platforms – iPhone, Android and Blackberry – when measured by user loyalty.
During the year 2010 Android emerged as the single best selling mobile platform in the US. Out of individual device types, however, the few iPhone models that are available on the market are actually selling more than any specific Android device, and for the time being, Apple’s well-controlled ecosystem, including the iTunes app store and traditionally higher revenues per device, seem to make an unmatched combination. As a platform, however, Android is a fair competitor –and in certain numbers, bigger than iPhone – but the industry attention is still geared towards the iPhone as the leading smartphone platform, particularly in the US.
Zokem, a mobile analytics company focused on smartphones, is running mobile consumer panels in all major markets. The panels do not only measure what people do with mobile phones, but also track how loyal people are towards different phone models and carriers.From the 2010 summary report that was published recently, a few figures are worth pointing out. First of all, “the figures suggest clearly that iPhone is the top performing platform in terms of user loyalty, and therefore, it is an increasingly likely pick for a repurchase” tells Dr. Hannu Verkasalo, CEO of Zokem. “Android is a good number two in the US market, even though the loyalty score is not nearly as high as it is for iPhones, but it seems that people who are using Android are also very likely to buy an Android-based device as their next smartphone too”, Verkasalo continues. Zokem is using a standardized net promoter score (NPS) to analyze user loyalty.
Figure 1.
Figure 1 reflects the loyalty that mobile users have for the phones that they are currently using. Net promoter score between -100 % and 100 %, is measuring the loyalty that people have towards the phone. Generically NPS score higher than 60 % is considered good. The only smartphone platform that exceeds that is iPhone, at 73 %. Google’s Android platform comes second, followed by Samsung’s Bada-based phones (Samsung has now shifted strategy more towards Android-based devices) and then RIM’s Blackberry phones. It is notable that two remarkable players, Nokia and Microsoft, received very low loyalty ratings for their own platforms. Also Palm’s Webos, sold to HP during year 2010, did not achieve a very high NPS score.
Figure 2.
Low loyalty correlates with higher churn, meaning the likelihood to shift to a competing platform during the next 12 months, as seen in Figure 2. There are, however, certain exceptions, like Samsung Bada, Palm WebOS, and Nokia Symbian S60. These platforms have suffered from lack of mass adoption, weak app stores, and relatively moderate push by US carriers. “Even though Samsung Bada, for example, received relatively good loyalty rating, most users were still committed to jump to one of the better known platforms, and therefore the churn for Bada was very high”, says Zhao Hanbo from the Zokem analyst team.
Figure 3
Figure 3 reflects some key correlations, underlining the fact that users of iPhones, Blackberries and Android devices are all more likely to buy a similar device in the future, rather than to change to a competing platform. The results are quite contrasting regarding Palm and Nokia phones, reflecting the fact that the weak platforms of today might be even weaker in the future.




